|
|
|
York 1999 |
|
| Page 3 of 3 |
The basic principle of closed circle anaesthesia is to reduce the anaesthetic gas and volatile agent consumption in line with the patient's own uptake while sustaining an adequate anaesthetic depth. This ensures a minimum release of surplus gases into the environment. The classical approach is to reduce the fresh gas flow to that of the patient's uptake. As a consequence the reaction time in the system is delayed dramatically. What in reality is needed is in fact a contradiction to the classical approach - a high gas flow will optimise the wash-in and wash-out characteristics due to the rapid reaction time of the system.
The evolution of a closed circuit anaesthesia system started with the Spirometer, used to measure oxygen uptake. The first step started was to modify a rolling seal respirometer so that it's bellow was driven by a time cycled external ventilator. The oxygen concentration was controlled using a feedback computer system set to a pre-determined value by an electronic dosage valve. The carrier gas, N2O or air, was used to balance the system volume values. The anaesthetic agents were administered manually by syringe injection in quantities based on the recommendations of Low & Ernst. The respirometer's circulation system, the Narcocon, created a high gas flow thus producing optimal conditions for maximal optimisation of wash-in and wash-out characteristics.
The second major step in the development process was the inclusion of an integrated flow-through chamber ventilator. The "Rotterdam" ventilator adapts to the patient lung volume by engaging or disengaging extra chambers without having any effect on the circulating gas flow. Ventilation is computer controlled by a feedback system that measures the volume displacements, corrected according to BTPS conditions, and adjusted to pre-set values.
The third step was the automatic computer controlled syringe injection of the selected anaesthetic agent, to pre-set end-expiratory or inspiratory values, into the high circulation gas flow. The gases are continuously analysed by the infra-red gas analyser.
The fourth step was the integration of this revolutionary new concept, named the PhysioFlex, into the modern clinical anaesthesia routine. This final and most important step took several years of clinical evaluation and technical adjustments before it was accepted.
The realisation of the high flow closed circuit anaesthesia
machine the PhysioFlex was only possible due to the dedication
of the multi-disciplinary team of physicians and technicians who
shared a dream 17 years ago.
Paediatric anaesthesia commonly involves the use of an open or semi-closed anaesthesia system with a relatively high gas flow. By closing such a system the advantages of the high flow together with the safety of the anaesthetic depth control are lost.
The PhysioFlex combines a closed system with high gas flow enabling optimal wash-in and wash-out of anaesthetic gases, therefore anaesthetic depth control is no longer a problem. Anaesthetic gases and agents are computer controlled and pre-set anaesthetic gas concentrations are maintained using feedback control, either via agent injection or adsorption by the charcoal filter.
The system volume, relatively high compared to the small lung volume of a child, was another challenge to be overcome during the development of the new paediatric function in the PhysioFlex. The exact system volume and the system compliance, including patient tubing, bacterial filters etc., are estimated for each intervention enabling the systems computer to compensate for the gas compression effect. The inspiratory flow has to be accurately controlled to avoid causing any damage to the child's fragile bronchial system.
To avoid the always-present peak pressure during IPPV, a selection was added to enable the anaesthetist to choose between volume controlled ventilation and Pressure Controlled Ventilation with smooth flow control. Feedback controlled dynamic PEEP was also introduced to compensate for the excessive PEEP fluctuations during surgical procedures.
A basic problem that is often neglected in paediatric ventilation is FRC maintenance. This can only be achieved in a system with a system volume control. This is unique to the PhysioFlex, which meticulously compensates for system volume loss due to uptake and/or leakage, for example due to an un-cuffed tube.
The computer program, linked to PCV, that manages all the requirements detailed above is called Automatic Lung Inflation Control Effect.
The use of to-and-fro circuits was described in 1936 by Ralph Waters (1). The original apparatus consisted of a solid steel container for soda-lime which was inserted between the fresh gas flow and rebreathing bag of what is now described as a Mapleson C circuit. This was used as an anaesthetic technique in the middle part of this century, but over the years has fallen out of common use. There were several reasons for this; it was not possible to measure the anaesthetic concentration; it was not possible to determine when the soda-lime was exhausted; it was heavy and cumbersome. Recently with the introduction of a new soda-lime absorber by Intersurgical (Wokingham, Berkshire, UK) there has been the opportunity to re-examine the use of a to-and-fro circuits in anaesthesia.
The basic concept was to develop a circuit which could be used in the theatre environment to provide general anaesthesia. To ensure that it was used as a closed circuit, it was decided to use a hydraulic piston ventilation technique (2), which would obviate the necessity to add further fresh gas to the circuit. A Penlon Nuffield ventilator was used with 20 metres of elephant tubing between it and the soda-lime absorber. Between the soda-lime absorber and the patient were ports for the input of a volatile anaesthetic and fresh gas, outlets for gas sampling and temperature monitoring, and a breathing filter.
I decided not to include a rebreathing bag in the circuit, as this was an unnecessary relic of prior circuits. In the final design there was no provision to return the sample gases to the circuit. This was part of the original design, and worked very well, until the para-magnetic oxygen analyser of the Datex Capnomac was repaired. This had an adverse effect on the circuit, and as a result the sampled gas was not returned. This is presumed to be a function of the gas analyser, and the circuit may perform differently with other analysers.
The circuit works well in practice, and has been used to give several anaesthetics of up to four hours duration. There are aspects of this circuit which are still being investigated, but it seems that, even with the sampled gas not returned to the circuit, it is a simple and cheap means of providing general anaesthesia for patients who are ventilated.
1. Waters RM. Carbon dioxide absorption technic in anesthesia.
Annals of Surgery (1936) 103:38-45
2. Walker TJ, Chakrabarti, MK, Lockwood GG. Uptake of Desflurane
during anaesthesia. Anaesthesia (1996) 51:33-36
Introduction. During sevoflurane anesthesia compound A can
be generated upon contact with alkaline CO2 absorbents. Its formation
is dependent upon multiple factors such as fresh gas flow rate:
the lesser the flow, the more compound A is formed. Limited data
exist on compound A production using true closed-circuit conditions,
performed with modern computer controlled liquid injection and
automatic volume and concentration control, as implemented in
the PhysioFlexâ (Dräger)1. Such data suggest that only
minor compound A concentrations are present in the circuit. In
order to substantiate this hypothesis a reproducible method for
sampling and quantitative analysis of compound A is indispensable.
Experimental. A protocol was developed allowing in-vitro testing
of multiple operational variables on compound A formation. Basically,
a PhysioFlexâ apparatus was connected to a testlung, wherein
CO2 was introduced. Gas concentrations were measured using a Datex
Ultima. Ventilation rate was 10/min. Prior to each experiment,
canisters were filled with fresh CO2-absorbent and new charcoal.
After baseline analysis, a set of sevoflurane concentration (ET)
was dialed on the apparatus for a duration of 120 min, whereafter
administration was halted. At baseline and at 5, 15, 30, 45, 60,
75, 90, 105, 120 min as well as at 5, 10 min after suspension
of sevoflurane several measurements were made including compound
Ainsp and compound Aexp. To that end, 2 ml gas samples were withdrawn,
in duplo, at the inspiratory and expiratory limb using 2.5 ml
gastight syringes, attached to the anesthesia circuit by means
of 3-way valves and luer-lock connections. Applying an overdraw
and compress technique, samples were then immediately transferred
into sealed glass headspace vials. Samples were then ready for
analysis and stored at room temperature for only a brief period
of time. Compound A determination was performed by gas chromatography
combined with mass-spectrometric detection (HP 6890-7359MSD).
Taken into account the large number of gaseous samples (analysis
duration of a complete experiment: 24h), their limited stability
and the fairly short analysis time for a single sample (20 min),
injection had to be fully automated from a practical point of
view. We therefore chose to apply a technique similar to head-space
extraction, using a computer controlled autosampler in conjunction
with a tray accommodating for 60 head-space vials to inject 1
ml of the gas phase. This technique offered not only full automation
of the method but also guarantied completely gastight and reproducible
injections. The use of a thick film capillary column (CP-select
624 with 6% cyanopropylphenyldimethylsilicone) allowed for excellent
separation, thus selectivity. Mass-spectrometric detection provided
high sensitivity and added to the selectivity. The assay for determination
of compound A furthermore is fully quantitative: prior to each
analysis a standard curve consisting of 8 points was prepared
and injected. Standards of compound A in the gas phase were prepared
departing from liquid volumetric dilutions of stock solutions
of compound A and sevoflurane in ethyl acetate.
Conclusion. This report describes uncomplicated and swift sampling
procedures as well as a sensitive and fully validated assay for
the quantitative determination of compound A in the gas phase.
Currently these methods are applied in investigating compound
A formation under various simulated closed circuit conditions.
Additionally, in-vivo experiments will be conducted in the near
future, using the same basic protocol.
ANESTHETIC GAS WASHIN TO THE CIRCLE SYSTEM: FILLING THE DELIVERY HOSES
We have been analyzing the pattern of anesthetic gas washin
to the circle C02 absorption system, washin similar to what one
would do prior to inhalation induction. Our goal is to be able
to recommend an efficient method which results in a gas concentration
throughout the circle equivalent to the delivered concentration.
This would be the ideal situation for single breath induction
and continuation with low flow anesthesia.
When washin is attempted by occluding the y-piece port while gas
fills the cannister and reservoir bag, no agent enters the delivery
hose portion of the circle regardless of how many times the bag
is emptied at the relief valve and refilled.
METHOD: In this project, using the approach to filling the system
just described, we delivered 8% sevoflurane to the circuit until
the % sevoflurane in the reservoir bag was >7%. At this time
no sevoflurane was detected at the y-piece. We then measured how
much gas had to be aspirated at the y-piece (as a patient would
have to do during induction) before the % sevoflurane was nearly
equal at the y-piece and reservoir bag. We compared volumes when
using 2 and 5 liter reservoir bags and when the delivery hoses
were fully compressed and fully expanded.
RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: With the hoses compressed, 600 ml, and
with them expanded, 1200 ml of gas had to be withdrawn for y-piece
and reservoir % sevoflurane to be nearly equal. As expected, the
volumes required were similar with the 2 and 5 liter bags. The
advantage of the 5 liter bag is that sufficient gas remains in
the bag for a vital capacity breath to allow a single breath induction
without additional gas from the machine. During and after the
first breaths of sevoflurane, management of stable anesthesia
should be possible with low flows when the large reservoir is
used. With the approach described here, the expiratory limb of
the delivery system still was not filled with sevoflurane.
Power Spectral Analysis of blood Pressure Fluctuation and Heart
Rate Variability in Low Flow Anesthesia with Isoflurane, Sevoflurane
or Desflurane
Minwen Yang, MD, Chung-Yuan Lin, MD
Department of Anesthesia, Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, Chang
Gung University, Taoyuan, Taiwan; Department of Anesthesia and
Critical Care, the University of Chicago Hospitals, Chicago, USA
The aim of this study is to evaluate the stability of the hemodynamic
responses in low flow anesthesia with three different inhalation
anesthetics- isoflurane, sevoflurane or desflurane, using the
power spectral analysis of blood pressure fluctuations and heart
rate variabilities. Methods: The study was approved by our institutional
research review board, and informed consent was obtained from
all patients. Sixty ASA physical status I or II adults of both
sexes were enrolled. Patients were randomly as signed to one of
three groups: isoflurane group (n=20), sevoflurane group (n=20)
and desflurane group (n=20). Premedication consisted of atropine
0.5 mg, and fentanyl 1.5 mcg/kg. Anesthesia was induced with sodium
pentothal 2-3 mg/kg. Endotracheal intubation was facilitated by
vecuronium 0.12 mg/kg. After the endotrachel intubation, we set
the two stages of total fresh gas flow (FGF): the first stage
for the filling out the anesthetic circuits and the FRC with the
FGF at O2 6000 ml/min for 4.5 min (about 3 time-constant), then
the second stage for the closing the circuit with the FGF at O2
500 ml/min for isoflurane group and desflurane group or with the
FGF at O2 1000 ml/min for sevoflurane group. The end-tidal concentration
of inhalation anesthetics was setting as isoflurane 1.6%, desflurane
6.8% or sevoflurane 2.0%, respectively. We also calculated the
effective blood concentration of three different inhalation anesthetics
according to the Lin's method. Data processing and spectral analysis:
Arterial blood pressure (SAP) and ECG signals were monitored by
Hewlett Packard 78354 monitor, digitized by using analog-to-digital
converter (PCL-812, Advantech) connected to the computer. The
SAP and ECG signals were digitized at 128 Hz, and were transferred
by the process of direct memory access to a 64-kB memory segment
in the random access memory defined as the circular buffer. For
each time (64s, 2048 data points), our algorithm first estimated
the power density of the spectral components based on fast Fourier
transform. We were interested in the low frequency components
of SAP and ECG spectra. These included the very low frequency
(VLF, 0.016-0.080 Hz), low frequency (LF, 0.08-0.15 Hz), high
frequency (HF, 0.15-0.25 Hz) components. The former three components
purported reflect the influence of vasomotor activity, baroreceptor
activity and respiration on SAP and ECG. Results: At an anesthetic
depth, arterial blood pressure, indices of sympathetic activity
derived from spectral analysis, decreased with three different
anesthetics.
Conclusion: Low flow anesthesia might provide a stable hemodynamic
response throughout operation procedure.
Introduction: The recent interest in earlier tracheal extubation
after coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) surgery has focused
our attention on inhalation anaesthesia instead of traditional
fentanyl anaesthesia. The present study was designed to investigate
the comparison between isoflurane (IBA) and fentanyl based anaesthesia
(FBA) in CABG surgery in terms of extubation time and intensive-care-unit
(ICU) staying time.
Methods: Our study included 123 patients (34 with poor ventricular
function) undergoing CABG surgery to receive either an IBA (n=72)
or FBA (n = 51) anesthetic. Induction of anaesthesia consisted
of fentanyl 15 mg/kg and midazolam 0.05 mg/kg intravenously in
the FBA group. The group received an additional bolus of fentanyl
5 mg/kg prior to sternotomy and fentanyl 10 mg/kg with pancuronium
0.1 mg/kg at the commencement of cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB).
In the IBA group, anaesthesia was induced with 2% isoflurane in
2 L/min O2 via mask for about 25 minutes and intubation was assisted
with pancuronium. And then the fresh gas flow was reduced to 300
ml O2/min with increased vaporizer setting of isoflurane up to
4-5% (about 12-15 ml/min of isoflurane vapor supply) for the maintenance
of anaesthesia.
Results: Patients in the IBA group were extubated earlier (8.7
± 10.7 h vs. 30+/-20 h, p < 0.001), and demonstrated
shorter ICU stay (2.3 ± 1.3 days vs. 3.9 ± 2 days,
p < 0.001) than in the FBA group. Both groups had acceptable
hemodynamic changes throughout anaesthesia, but the inotropic
requirements for better hemodynamic maintenace were more in the
FBA group than in the IBA group (dopamine: 4 ± 2.6 vs.
0.7 ± 1.5, p < 0.001; dobutamine: 3.7 ± 3.3 vs.
0.0.5 ± 1.9; p< 0.001).
Discussion: The results of the IBA method in CABG surgery demonstrated
that isoflurane with minimal low flow technique is an alternative
anesthesia technique for CABG surgery, even for patients with
limited cardiac reserve. Additionally, the IBA method can facilitate
the fast track cardiac surgery.
Introduction: The body uptake of isoflurane was determined
using the difference (between inspired isoflurane (FI iso) and
end-expired isoflurane (FE iso) multiplied by alveolar ventilation
or that (between arterial isoflurane (A iso) and pulmonary arterial
mixed venous isoflurane (PA iso), multiplied by cardiac output.
There are few studies to look into measuring A iso and PA iso
simultaneously from the beginning of isoflurane in humans. The
study was designed to investigate the simultaneous measurements
of FE iso, A iso, PA iso when FI iso kept at 2% in patients undergoing
coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery.
Methods: Following IRB approval, 10 patients, aged 50-78 years
old, selectively scheduled to undergo CABG surgery, were included
in the study. A 20-gauged arterial cannula and a Swan-Ganz catheter
under local anaesthesia were inserted into a radial and a pulmonary
artery, respectively. The breathing circuit was prewashed with
2% isoflurane in 6-L oxygen for 3 minutes before mask induction
with 2% isoflurane in 2-liter oxygen for 25 minutes. Intubation
was facilitated with 8 mg pancuronium. Inspired concentration
of isoflurane was maintained about 2% in 300 ml oxygen during
next 95-minute anaesthesia. Anesthetic gas concentrations were
monitored with a multiage analyzer. FI iso, FE iso, end-tidal
CO2 and vital sign of each patient were recorded every 10 seconds.
Cardiac output was measured intermittently. Two 2-ml blood each
time, from arterial and pulmonary arterial accesses, respectively,
for isoflurane measurement in the following time intervals: 1,
2, 5, 10, 20, 30, 60, 90, 120 minutes. Isoflurane concentrations
in arterial and pulmonary arterial blood were determined using
head-space gas chromatography with flame-ionization detector.
Results: The FE iso increased rapidly within 5 minutes and then
became gradually slowly increasing throughout the remaining 115
minutes. FE iso was kept much higher than A iso throughout the
study and its difference was almost same except the initial 5
minutes. The differences between FI iso and FE iso as well as
between A iso and PA iso against time were almost the same within
120 minutes, but it was less between A iso and PA iso than between
FI iso and FE iso.
Discussions: Our results show that the uptake of isoflurane, according
to the differences between FA iso and FE iso or between A iso
and PA iso, kept near constant amount during 120-minute period.
The membrane factor is a limited step in diffusion between pulmonary
alveolar and capillary since the difference between FE iso and
A iso exists during the whole study. No clinically significant
change in blood pressure and heart rate was noted within 120-minute
isoflurane anaesthesia. It indicates that we are able to practice
minimal-low-flow anesthesia safely and easily once we fill the
functional residual capacity with anesthetic at high flow initially.
Introduction: The goal of isoflurane in clinical practice should
be safely and conveniently reach adequate partial pressure in
the brain to anesthetize patients. Although brain isoflurane partial
pressure cannot be measured directly in patients, it could be
represented by isoflurane concentration in the internal jugular
bulb blood (JB iso). Furthermore, brain uptake of isoflurane can
be estimated using the concentration difference between arterial
blood (A iso) and JB iso when we assume cerebral blood flow remains
constant. The study was looked into brain isoflurane uptake in
patients under isoflurane anaesthesia.
Methods: Following IRB approval, 7 ASA I-II patients underwent
elective colorectal surgery under isoflurane anaesthesia. A 20-gauged
catheter and a single-lumen central venous catheter were inserted
into a radial artery and a internal jugular bulb under local anaesthesia,
respectively. The breathing circuit was prewashed with 2% isoflurane
in 6 L oxygen for 3 minutes. Anaesthesia was induced with fentanyl
100 mg, and thiopentone 5-6 mg/kg and intubation was facilitated
with pretreated pancuronium (0.015 mg/kg) and succinylcholine
(1.25 mg/kg). For maintenance of anaesthesia, inspired concentration
of 2% isoflurane in 2 L oxygen was given for 30 minutes and then
300 ml oxygen applied with adjusting vaporizer setting to keep
the inspired concentration of isoflurane at 2%. Anaesthetic gas
concentrations were monitored with a multiage analyzer. The inspired
and end-expired isoflurane (FE iso) concentration, end-tidal CO2,
blood pressure and heart rate were recorded every 10 seconds.
Two 2-ml blood each time, for A iso and JB iso measurements were
withdrawn in the following time intervals: 1, 2, 5, 10, 20, 30,
60, 90, 120 minutes. The A iso and JB iso were determined using
head-space gaschromatography flame-ionization detector.
Results: The FE iso concentration was increased rapidly within
the first five minutes and the rate of increase slowed down during
next 115 minutes. The rates of increase A iso and JB iso were
similar to that of FE iso but lower than FE iso. Interestingly,
the concentration difference between A iso and JB iso became small
at 30-minute point and no difference between A iso and JB iso
from 60-minute point on was found.
Discussion: Our study demonstrates that the brain uptake of isoflurane
is different from the whole body uptake of it. After 30-minute
administration of isoflurane, brain is almost saturated with it.
The pharmacodynamic meaning implicated by pharmacokinetic phenomenon
is not clear and needs further studies.
Introduction
The inert gas xenon is regarded to be the ideal inhalation anesthetic.
Its routine use failed because of high costs of the substance.
Recycling devices and the use of closed anesthesia systems have
renewed the interest in xenon anesthesia.
The organ kinetic of xenon has not been yet investigated under
conditions of anesthesia. We therefore investigated the correlation
between expiratory xenon concentrations and body content of xenon
in different compartments..
Material and methods
7 pigs were anesthetized with an inspiratory concentration of
70% xenon in closed system anesthesia. Anesthesia time was 4 hours,
washout phase was 2 hours. Inert xenon 131 was marked with radioactive
xenon 133. Organ distribution was measured with a double head
gamma camera. Expiratory xenon concentrations were measured by
mass spectrometer. Measured activities of radioactive xenon were
correlated with expiratory measured xenon concentrations. Correlation
coefficients were calculated for the compartments whole body,
fatty tissue, lung and bowels.
Results
After the washout phase 27.15% of the measured activity remained
in the animals. Simoultaneously expiratory concentrations of only
0.22% of xenon were measured. Correlation coefficients were found
for whole body: 0.87, fatty tissue 0.64, lung: 0.98, bowels: 0.54.
Discussion
Measuring expiratory xenon concentrations is a good prediction
of the organ kinetic of distribution compartments with fast kinetics
like the lung. Distribution spaces with slow kinetics like fatty
tissue or bowels are less accurately included in the predictions.
From the expiratory measured xenon concentration the amount of
xenon remeining in the tissues cannot be calculated exactly. These
results have to be considered in kinetic calculations of all inhalation
anesthetics.
Fig.1: Xenon organ kinetics in whole body and bowels (measuring
point 30 minutes) Image in preparation
Pollution of the global and the working environment can be
reduced by low-flow- and minimal flow anaesthesia with the additional
benefit of reduced expenditure on anaesthetic agents. Xenon is
a rare and expensive anaesthetic agent and must be used in a safe
and cost-effective manner.
Accumulation of nitrogen is a concern in minimal-flow and closed
system anaesthesia. In closed system anaesthesia it leads to a
reduction of the anaesthetic agent's concentration. Three concepts
of denitrogenation have been described:
1. Denitrogenation with a high fresh gas flow (FGF) for 5 to 25
minutes in an open system followed by changing the patient onto
a closed system thereafter. Using this procedure, nitrogen concentrations
of 3.5% - 14% have been reported in anaesthesias lasting from
34 - 165 minutes.
2. Denitrogenation using a FGF of 4 l/min in a rebreathing system
with a subsequent reduction in flow to that of closed system anaesthesia.
Nitrogen accumulation was measured ranging from 12% - 16 % in
2 hours of anaesthesia.
3. Denitrogenation for 5- 10 minutes using a FGF of 4- 5 l/min
and reduction to 1 l/min (low-flow anaesthesia). In low-flow-anaesthesia
nitrogen accumulation is not considered a problem.
Our investigation aimed to avoid rebreathing of nitrogen during the denitrogenation phase by using a semi-open ventilator and to minimise xenon usage by using closed system anaesthesia. Nitrogen accumulation in our closed system and xenon expenditure were measured in comparison to low-flow anaesthesia.
Methods and Results
After consent of the animal care commission, 14 pigs were anaesthetised
with xenon, administered in an inspiratory concentration of 70%.
Anaesthesia was inducted with a bolus dose of 8 mg/kg bodyweight
of pentobarbital and 0.01 mg/kg buprenorphine. Neuromuscular relaxation
was provided by a single dose of 0.25 mg/kg alcuroniumchloride.
Xenon 70% in oxygen was administered in a rebreathing system (Draeger
Cicero, Draegerwerk Luebeck, Germany) calibrated for xenon anaesthesia
by the manufacturer. In group 1, the FGF was set to 1 l/min (0.5
l/min Xenon / 0.5 l/min oxygen). To achieve denitrogenation, the
flow was increased to 3 l/min during the first five minutes of
anaesthesia (3). Group 2 was denitrogenated in a semi-open ventilator
(Draeger Oxylog) using oxygen 100% for 20 minutes and then connected
to the xenon-ventilator primed with xenon and oxygen (70:30).
Xenon and oxygen flows first were set to uptake values calculated
by the computer simulation program "Narkup 4.03" (White
and Lockwood, Northwick Park Hospital, Harrow, Middlesex) and
then held constant by the measured values. Both groups were anaesthetised
for 2 hours. Mass-spectrometry was used to measure inspired and
expired xenon, oxygen and nitrogen levels with the analysed sample
reintroduced into the closed system to minimise wastage. In the
low flow group no reintroduction into the system was available.
The gas-expenditure was calculated from the fresh-gas flows in
group 1 and in group 2 by weighing xenon bottles before and after
anaesthesia.
For statistic analysis the Mann-Whitney-U-test was used for comparisons
(p = 0.05).
Xenon expenditure in group 1 was calculated at 67 l over the
2 hours of anaesthesia. In group 2 we measured a xenon expenditure
of 7.58 liters (Median. 25. percentile - 75. percentile: 6.42
l-9.5 l) for the same time period.
The nitrogen concentrations are shown in table 1.
Table 1
Comment
Denitrogenation in a semi-open system avoids rebreathing of nitrogen.
We measured lower nitrogen concentrations in our closed system
than Luttrop et al. using the same system (12%-16% vs. 0.7%-3.8%).
There was no significant difference between nitrogen concentrations
in our closed and low-flow system.
Xenon usage was in the same range as in the experiments of Luttrop.
The use of closed-system anaesthesia resulted in a ten-fold decrease
in xenon expenditure as compared to low-flow-anaesthesia. We conclude
that a separate denitrogenation phase in a semi-open system improves
closed system anaesthesia and can be used routineously in anaesthetic
practice. This may be especially useful whilst monitoring lines
and catheters are being inserted post-induction. For more convenience,
the denitrogenation system could be integrated in the main ventilator.
Additionally, the priming volume of the system can be reused if
washout is achieved by the second ventilator system, leading to
a further reduction of the xenon expenditure by a volume equivalent
to the deadspace of the ventilator ( 4.5 l approximately).
In short duration procedures no period of washout is possible
and recycling systems which separate xenon from nitrogen and oxygen
are preferable.
Tables
|
Time of measurement (min) |
Group 1 (low-flow) Nitrogen conc. (%) Median (25.-75. Perc.) |
Group 2 (closed system) Nitrogen conc. (%) Median (25.-75. Perc.) |
| 0 | 2.88 (1.9-5.9) | 0.88 (0.07-5.1) |
| 10 | 2.82 (1.5-5.5) | 0.77 (0.07-5.1) |
| 20 | 1.89 (1.39-3.56) | 1.04 (0.07-5.18) |
| 30 | 5.38 (0.92-5.69) | 1.17 (0.07-5.15) |
| 40 | 0.98 (0.74-2.23) | 1.22 (0.07-5.26) |
| 50 | 0.81 (0.63-1.17) | 1.26 (0.08-5.44) |
| 60 | 0.83 (0.74-2.59) | 1.29 (0.08-5.31) |
| 70 | 1.30 (0.84-3.76) | 1.37 (0.08-5.35) |
| 80 | 2.95 (0.91-5.55) | 1.7 (0.08-5.67) |
| 90 | 2.21 (0.73-4.86) | 1.84 (0.08-5.59) |
| 100 | 1.23 (0.75-3.62) | 3.62 (0.08-6.80) |
| 110 | 1.39 (0.74-1.97) | 3.2 (0.08-6.27) |
| 120 | 1.78 (0.82-3.37) | 3.8 (0.08-7.04) |
Table 1: Nitrogen concentrations in % in the ventilator circle system in group 1 (low-flow-anaesthesia) and group 2 (closed system anaesthesia). No significant differences
Fig.1: Concentrations of xenon, nitrogen and oxygen during 4 hours of anesthesia. Image in preparation
The accumulation of trace gases resulting from human metabolism is a problem of minimal flow and closed circuit anesthesia. Infrared spectrometry, Raman spectrometry or mass spectrometry are used to measure gas concentrations in closed rebreathing systems. Infrared spectrometry basically measures the absorption of infrared light by the chemical bonds of different molecules. Methane (CH4) is measured in the range of 3.6 mm and 7.7 mm where infrared light is absorbed by the C-H bond. Enflurane and isoflurane have absorption bands at 8-10 mm, halothane at 8.5 - 8.8 mm. In addition to these specific wavelengths of absorption, all non-aromatic hydrocarbons, including volatile anesthetics, absorb infrared light at 3.2-3.6 mm, as long as one or more C-H bond exists in the molecule.
More than 100 different organic substances have been identified in human breath. The most important of them are acetone, isoprene and acetonitrile. Peroxides are exhaled under ARDS conditions.
In a study carried out by Versichelen and co-workers using
gas chromatography, methane concentrations up to 800 ppm were
detected. The infrared spectrometer of the anesthetic circuit,
calibrated for halothane and measuring at a wavelength of 3.6
mm, indicated false-postive measurements of halothane within a
range of 1 % (10,000 ppm). In another investigation, anattempt
was made to measure methane accumulation during closed circuit
anaesthesia using a Brüel & Kjaer 1302 infrared monitor.
The Brüel & Kjaer monitor is a technical variation of
an infrared spectrometer. The monitor measures gas concentrations
of up to 5 gases simultaneously at specific single absorption
bands. Cross-interferences of known substances are compensated.
Methane concentrations up to 941 ppm were detected, the results
were interpreted based on the differences in metabolism and nutrition
of the patients. Although no halothane was used in the anesthetic
procedures, the monitor of the ventilation apparatus "Physioflex"
falsely measured halothane at a wavelength of 3.6 mm. Concentrations
of up to 0.79% (7900 ppm) were detected. Statistic calculations
demonstrated positive correlations between the concentrations
of halothane and methane.
Our experiment was carried out to demonstrate the influences of
cross-interferences of organic hydrocarbons in infrared spectrometry.
Methods
The experimental setup consisted of a partial rebreathing system.
A test lung was ventilated with a fresh-gas flow of 0.5 l /min
and a breathing volume of 8 l /min. An oxygen/air mixture was
used as carrier gas. The rubber tubes of the system were new.
The ventilator had not been in use for more than one year. A multi-gas
monitor Brüel & Kjaer 1302, calibrated for isoflurane,
methane, acetone, and ethanol was used to measure trace gas concentrations
in the system. After establishing baseline values, 1 ml of acetone,
ethanol, propanol and acetaldehyde in 100 ml of aqueous solution
were atomized in the system by a medical atomizer. The substances
were added after each hour of ventilation.
Results
Image in preparation
Fig.1
Acetone and ethanol concentrations were detected by the multi-gas monitor (Fig 1, C: acetone, maximum concentration 661 ppm, D: ethanol, maximum concentration 204 ppm, starting point of vaporisation of acetone at point I, ethanol at point II). Cross-interferences were compensated. Methane was initially measured at a concentration of 57 ppm, which exceeds the natural concentration of methane (1.8 ppm) (E). Addition of isopropanol (point III) increased the measured concentrations of methane from 22 ppm to 92 ppm and those of isoflurane (B) from 6 ppm to 14 ppm, although these substances were not added to the system. H2O2 did not interfere with the results (point IV). Adding acetaldehyde (V) increased the measured methane concentration from 80 ppm to 102 ppm, isoflurane from 12 ppm to 26 ppm and ethanol from 170 ppm to 204 ppm.
Discussion
For detecting accumulations of hydrocarbonic trace substances
by infrared monitors, cross compensation is only possible if these
gases can be measured at alternative specific wavelengths with
the monitor calibrated for the substances. The vaporisation of
acetaldehyde and isopropanol in our experiment clearly led to
invalid measurements of trace gases because the monitor was not
calibrated for these substances and interpreted the absorption
maxima as methane, ethanol or even isoflurane.
The 3.2-3.6 mm and 7.7 mm absorption bands are the only suitable
ones for measuring methane. Because any non-aromatic hydrocarbon
will absorb infrared light at the same wavelength as methane,
the increased methane concentrations in the first phase of our
experiment were probably attributable to cross-interferences with
organic volatiles emitted from the new rubber tubes of the system
or to traces of volatile anesthetics remaining in the ventilator.
Also, another cause might be enrichment of methane in compressed
air. Infrared spectroscopy proves to not be feasible for interpreting
these measured values.
Organic volatiles exhaled by humans are detected in the ppb (parts
per billion) or ppm (parts per million) range. Because these organic
volatiles possess long C-H chains, each of them absorb infrared
light in the 3.6 mm area and have higher molecular weights than
methane. The amount of interferences caused by the sum of more
than 100 different organic compounds should not be regarded as
insignificant. The results of a former study that simultaneously
measured methane by gas chromatography within a range of 850 ppm
and false-positive halothane concentrations within a range of
10,000 ppm give an impression of the problem's quantitative importance.
Our experiment demonstrated the fact that cross-interferences
exist in infrared spectroscopy. Thus, we conclude that it is neither
possible to measure exact methane concentrations by infrared spectrometry
in closed-system anaesthesia nor to interprete these results based
on the differences in metabolism or nutrition.
Nevertheless, the methane concentration could be used as a rough
estimation of the concentration of the sum total of all organic
volatiles possessing C-H bonds. To obtain the best results, either
mass spectrometry or gas chromatography should be preferred.
Infrared measurement of volatile anesthetics in anaesthetic ventilators
should be carried out at different wavelength than in the 3.6
mm area.
This page uploaded March 2003